Best Practices for CRM Data Migration: A Complete Guide

Data migration is the most underestimated phase of any CRM implementation. It's rarely glamorous, it's often tedious, and when done poorly, it can undermine even the most sophisticated CRM deployment. We've seen organizations invest hundreds of thousands of dollars in a new platform only to fill it with dirty, duplicate, and disorganized data from their legacy system — effectively building a beautiful house on a crumbling foundation.

This guide walks through the complete data migration process, from initial planning to post-migration validation. Whether you're moving from spreadsheets to your first CRM, migrating between platforms, or consolidating multiple systems into one, these practices will help you get it right.

Phase 1: Planning and Scoping

Every successful migration starts with a clear plan. Before you touch a single record, you need to answer several critical questions:

What data is being migrated? Contacts, companies, deals, activities, emails, attachments, custom fields, notes — define the scope explicitly. Not everything in your old system needs to come along.
What's the timeline? Migrations done under pressure produce errors. Build in buffer time for testing and validation — typically 20–30% more than your initial estimate.
Who owns the process? Assign a migration lead who has both technical capability and business context. They need to understand what the data means, not just how to move it.
What does success look like? Define specific acceptance criteria: record counts, field completion rates, relationship integrity, and user-verified spot checks.

Document your plan in a migration playbook that your entire team can reference. This isn't bureaucracy — it's insurance against the chaos that inevitably surfaces mid-migration.

Phase 2: Data Audit and Discovery

Before you clean a single record, you need to understand exactly what you're working with. Export your existing data and conduct a thorough audit:

Record counts by entity type. How many contacts, companies, deals, and activities exist? Are these numbers reasonable, or do they suggest years of accumulated junk?
Field usage analysis. Which fields are consistently populated? Which ones are empty 90% of the time? Fields with less than 20% fill rates are candidates for elimination.
Duplicate detection. Run deduplication analysis on names, email addresses, phone numbers, and company names. Most legacy systems contain 15–30% duplicate records.
Data quality assessment. Check for formatting inconsistencies (phone numbers in five different formats), outdated information (contacts who left the company years ago), and invalid entries (test records, placeholder data).

This audit will inevitably surface uncomfortable truths about your data quality. That's the point. It's far better to discover these issues now than after go-live.

Phase 3: Data Cleansing

With your audit complete, it's time to clean. This is the most labor-intensive phase, and it's the one most teams try to shortcut. Don't. Every hour spent cleaning data saves multiple hours of frustration after migration.

Merge duplicates. Use automated deduplication tools where possible, but plan for manual review of ambiguous matches. Automated merging without human oversight will inevitably combine records that shouldn't be combined.
Standardize formats. Phone numbers, addresses, state abbreviations, country names, industry classifications — pick a standard and apply it consistently.
Purge obsolete records. Contacts who haven't been engaged in five years, deals that were abandoned three years ago, companies that no longer exist — these don't belong in your new system.
Enrich incomplete records. For high-value contacts and accounts, invest time in filling in missing fields. Tools like ZoomInfo, Clearbit, or LinkedIn Sales Navigator can help automate enrichment.
Validate email addresses. Run your contact list through an email verification service. Importing thousands of invalid emails will damage your sender reputation and skew engagement metrics.

Phase 4: Field Mapping

Field mapping is the technical bridge between your old system and your new one. For each field in your source system, you need to define where it goes in the target system — and how it gets transformed along the way.

Common mapping challenges include:

Field type mismatches. Your old system stored "Industry" as free text; your new system uses a dropdown. You'll need to create a mapping table that translates every free-text variation to the correct dropdown value.
Structural differences. Your old system stored address as a single field; your new system has separate fields for street, city, state, and zip. You'll need parsing logic.
Relationship preservation. Contacts linked to companies, deals linked to contacts, activities linked to deals — these associations must be maintained through the migration. This typically requires migrating entities in a specific order and using ID mapping tables.
Custom fields. Any custom fields from your old system need corresponding fields in your new system. This is the time to evaluate whether those custom fields are still needed.

Create a comprehensive field mapping document — a spreadsheet that lists every source field, its target field, the transformation logic, and any notes about edge cases. This document becomes your migration specification.

Phase 5: Test Migration

Never migrate directly to production. Always run at least one — preferably two or three — test migrations in a sandbox environment first.

Start with a subset. Migrate 100–500 representative records first. Check every field, every relationship, every custom property. Fix issues before scaling up.
Then run a full test. Migrate the complete dataset into your sandbox. Validate record counts, run integrity checks, and have end users spot-check records they're familiar with.
Document every issue. Create a migration defect log that tracks every problem found, its root cause, and the fix applied. This log becomes your quality assurance checklist for the production migration.

Test migrations will always reveal issues you didn't anticipate. That's their entire purpose. Treat each issue as a gift — it's one less problem you'll face on go-live day.

Phase 6: Production Migration

With your test migrations validated and issues resolved, you're ready for the real thing. A few critical guidelines:

Schedule wisely. Run the production migration during a low-activity period — typically a weekend or after business hours. This minimizes the risk of data conflicts from concurrent usage.
Freeze the source system. If possible, make the legacy system read-only during migration to prevent new records from being created that won't make it to the new platform.
Run your migration script exactly as tested. This is not the time for improvisation. Use the same tools, the same sequence, and the same parameters you validated in testing.
Monitor in real time. Watch for errors, timeouts, and API rate limits. Have your migration lead available throughout the process to make judgment calls on issues that arise.

Phase 7: Post-Migration Validation

The migration isn't done when the data lands in the new system. Validation is what separates a migration from a data dump.

Record count reconciliation. Compare total records by entity type between source and target. Any discrepancies need investigation and explanation.
Field-level spot checks. Have team members review 50–100 records they know well. Do the details look right? Are relationships intact? Are notes and activities attached to the correct records?
Report validation. Run the same reports in both old and new systems. Do the numbers match? Pipeline totals, contact counts by owner, deal values by stage — these should align.
User acceptance testing. Have each department's power users spend a day working in the new system with the migrated data. Collect feedback systematically and prioritize fixes.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Migrating everything. Not all data deserves a new home. Be ruthless about leaving behind obsolete, duplicate, and low-value records.
Skipping the data audit. "We'll clean it up after migration" is the rallying cry of projects that never get cleaned up. Clean before you migrate.
Underestimating timeline. Data migration typically takes 2–3x longer than initial estimates. Plan accordingly.
Ignoring user training on the new data model. Even perfectly migrated data is useless if users don't understand where to find things in the new system.
No rollback plan. Have a documented process for reverting to the legacy system if the migration goes catastrophically wrong. You'll probably never need it, but you'll sleep better knowing it exists.

Data migration may not be the most exciting part of a CRM implementation, but it's arguably the most important. Get it right, and your team starts day one with clean, organized, trustworthy data. Get it wrong, and you'll spend months — sometimes years — paying for shortcuts that seemed reasonable at the time.

At The CRM Experts, we've managed data migrations involving hundreds of thousands of records across every major CRM platform. If you're planning a migration and want to ensure it goes smoothly, we're here to help.

Back to Blog